Choosing Your Care Provider: Finding Someone Who Supports Your Vision
Most of us choose a care provider the same way we choose a dentist.
Whoever was recommended by a friend. Whoever was covered by our insurance. Whoever had availability when we called. And then we stay, even when something feels off, because we don’t realize we have other options, or because we think it is too late to change.
This episode is about changing that.
The way your provider speaks to you in a 15-minute prenatal appointment is a preview of how they will show up when you are in your most vulnerable moment. If you leave appointments feeling dismissed, unheard, or like your questions were an inconvenience. That is information and you are allowed to act on it.
I Switched Providers Three Times (The Last Time at 33 Weeks)
During my first pregnancy, I switched care providers three times. The last switch happened at 33 weeks pregnant. I remember feeling like it was too late, like I had missed my window, like I just needed to make the best of where I was.
But I didn’t feel supported. And I knew that if I didn’t feel comfortable in a short prenatal appointment, I was not going to feel comfortable when I was in the most vulnerable moment of my life.
So I switched. And it made all the difference.
You are allowed to do the same. It is not too late at 28 weeks. It is not too late at 33 weeks. The right provider will not make you feel like asking questions is too much. They will welcome it.
Know What You Are Looking For FirstÂ
Before you can find the right provider, you need to know what you actually want. A few questions worth sitting with before your next appointment:
- How do I want to feel during my prenatal appointments: heard, informed, and respected?
- How much involvement do I want from my provider during labor?
- How do I feel about interventions? Do I want someone who waits and watches, or someone who moves more quickly?
- How important is it to me to know the provider who will actually be there when I give birth?
- How do I want decisions to be made? Am I looking for a partner in my care, or do I prefer to lean heavily on my provider’s guidance?
There are no wrong answers. But knowing yours helps you find the right fit.Â
OBs vs. Midwives: What Each Typically Offers
Obstetricians are surgically trained physicians who specialize in obstetric care. Their expertise is in managing high-risk pregnancies, complications, and surgical deliveries including C-sections. Because of this, many OBs have limited exposure to unmedicated, physiological births because that is not the majority of what they see. Most OBs practice in hospitals and are often part of a rotating call schedule, which means the provider you see throughout pregnancy may not be the one who attends your birth.
Midwives specialize in low-risk, normal pregnancy, labor, birth, and postpartum care. Midwifery care tends to be more relationship-based and individualized. Appointments are often longer, and midwives are generally more familiar with supporting labor without medication. Certified Nurse-Midwives (CNMs) can practice in hospitals, birth centers, and some home birth settings. Certified Professional Midwives (CPMs) are trained specifically for out-of-hospital birth.
Â
The most important thing is not the credential, rather it is the individual provider’s philosophy and how they practice. Some OBs are deeply supportive of natural labor. Some midwives are more intervention-oriented than you might expect. What matters most is finding the specific person whose approach aligns with yours.
The Reality of Rotating Providers
When I switched to my final practice at 33 weeks, I joined a group of six midwives. I made it a point to meet all six before my due date. Some I connected with more than others — but I felt that all of them knew their work and aligned with supporting my preferences.
And STILL, the midwife who attended my birth was someone I had never met. The hospital had additional midwives on rotation beyond my practice.
But here is what made it work. She had my birth preferences on file before she ever walked in the room. The first thing she said was that it looked like I was handling contractions well, so she would check in but otherwise give me space. That was exactly what I needed and it happened because my preferences were documented and my husband knew them, not because I had a personal relationship with her.
Â
This is why your husband knowing your preferences is just as important as you knowing them. The person who walks in may be a stranger. Your husband is not.
A Note About Hospital Nurses
Your nurse is a significant part of your labor experience and often more present than your provider during the actual laboring hours. And something worth knowing: many hospital nurses have limited experience supporting unmedicated labor. Their toolkit typically includes IV pain medication or an epidural, not because they don’t care, but because that is what the majority of their patients use.
Shift changes also happen. You may have a nurse you love at 2pm and someone completely different at 8pm. You cannot control that. What you can control is making sure your preferences are documented, your husband knows them, and your support team can hold the line regardless of who walks through the door.
Â
The people guaranteed to be there are your husband, your doula if you have one, and anyone else you have specifically chosen. Build your support around those people, not whoever happens to be on call.
What to Ask When You Interview a Provider
- How do you typically support laboring patients? Listen for whether her description sounds like what you are hoping for. Does she mention movement, monitoring options, freedom to labor at your own pace? Or does it sound more protocol-driven?
- What is your availability during my labor and what happens if you are not there? In many practices, the provider you have built a relationship with may not be the one who attends your birth. Who is the back-up? Can you meet them?
- How do you approach interventions? Ask her to describe her philosophy, not to make promises. Does she take a watchful, patient-led approach? Does she tend to move things along? What does she typically try first when labor stalls?
- How do you feel about support people being actively involved, including doulas and husbands? Listen carefully here. A provider who values your support team will say so specifically. One who sidelines them will reveal that too.
- How do you approach decision-making with your patients? Does she see you as a partner in your care? Does she explain options or expect you to follow her lead?
- What are the policies at your birth location that I should know about? This helps you understand what is driven by her philosophy and what is hospital or birth center policy and where the two might conflict with your preferences.
Red Flags That Sound Reasonable on the Surface
Before I made my final switch, I interviewed a provider whose answers were not obviously wrong, but they told me everything.
When I asked how she felt about doulas, she said she was fine with them as long as they stayed out of her way and hung out in the corner. Technically accurate because doulas cannot make medical decisions. But what she didn’t acknowledge was the value of having a knowledgeable, experienced support person in the room. The framing said everything about how she viewed labor support.
Then she mentioned that if she were doing labor again herself, she would choose more interventions earlier.
Neither of those statements is outrageous. But together they told me her philosophy did not align with mine. I only knew that because I asked.
The questions matter. And so does listening to the answers carefully.
You Are Allowed to Switch
If something doesn’t feel right, if you finish appointments feeling unheard, if your questions are brushed aside, if a provider’s answers reveal a philosophy that doesn’t match yours, you do not have to stay.
It is worth noting that switching providers mid-pregnancy, while emotionally harder, is easier to do than switching a nurse or provider during labor. You have a relationship with your prenatal provider. You do not have a relationship with the nurse who just walked in at the start of her shift, which means asking for a different care team member during labor, while uncomfortable, is actually a more straightforward request than most women realize.
Â
God has placed genuinely gifted, caring providers in this world. Ask Him to guide you to the right one. And then do the practical work of asking the right questions.
Your One Step This Week
“Where there is no guidance, a people falls, but in an abundance of counselors there is safety.” – Proverbs 11:14
Write down three things that matter most to you in a provider (not a birth location, not a birth plan, just the person). How you want to feel in their care? What approach you are hoping for? What questions you still haven’t asked?
Then bring those three things to your next appointment and pay attention to how the conversation goes.
If it goes well, you may have found your person.
Â
If it doesn’t, you know what to do…
Free Download: This Episode Only